S. D. V. Stephens

notes / Studies in Algebra and Group Theory / chapter 1: Sets and Groups / From my book

B3.3 The Isomorphism Theorems

The isomorphism theorems describe how quotients, subgroups, and homomorphisms interact. They reappear essentially unchanged for rings, vector spaces, and modules; Chapter 8 develops a language in which this common pattern can be stated once.

3.3.1 The First Isomorphism Theorem

Recall the kernel and image of a homomorphism (Definition 2.5.5): is a subgroup of , is a subgroup of , and is injective if and only if (Proposition 2.5.6). By Theorem 3.1.10, is moreover a normal subgroup, so is a group.

Lemma 3.3.1 (Fibers of a homomorphism). Let be a homomorphism and . Then

Proof. . The last equivalence is Proposition 3.1.2. ∎

When does a homomorphism out of induce a homomorphism out of a quotient ? Exactly when it kills .

Theorem 3.3.2 (Factoring through a quotient). Let be a homomorphism, let , and let be the canonical projection. There exists a map with if and only if .

Diagram

In that case is unique, given by ; it is a homomorphism; ; and .

Proof. If exists, then for we have , so .

Conversely, suppose . If , then , so by Lemma 3.3.1. Thus is constant on each coset of , and is well defined (Proposition 1.6.4); by construction . Any with must be given by this formula, because is surjective. It is a homomorphism: Its image is . Finally, if and only if , so . ∎

Theorem 3.3.3 (First Isomorphism Theorem). Let be a homomorphism. Then , and the map is an isomorphism. In particular, if is surjective, then .

Proof. Normality of is Theorem 3.1.10. Apply Theorem 3.3.2 with : the map is a homomorphism with image and kernel , the identity element of . So is injective (Proposition 2.5.6) and surjective onto . ∎

In slogan form: the image of a homomorphism is isomorphic to the domain modulo the kernel.

Note. The First Isomorphism Theorem is sometimes called the “fundamental theorem of homomorphisms.” It says that every homomorphism factors as a surjection, followed by an isomorphism, followed by an inclusion.

Example 3.3.4 (The First Isomorphism Theorem at work).

  1. Reduction mod (Example 2.5.7) is a surjective homomorphism from onto the group with addition mod of Example 2.2.3, with kernel . So the quotient group is isomorphic to that group, and the two descriptions of agree.
  2. The map is a surjective homomorphism from onto the circle group under multiplication, with kernel . Hence . Each coset contains exactly one number in , namely the fractional part of , so is the group with addition mod 1 of Example 2.2.4.
  3. The determinant (Section 5.4) is a homomorphism . It is surjective, since , and its kernel is . Hence .
  4. The conjugation homomorphism of Section 3.2.3 has image and kernel (Proposition 3.2.13). Hence .

3.3.2 The Second and Third Isomorphism Theorems

For subsets we write .

Theorem 3.3.5 (Second Isomorphism Theorem). Let be a group, a subgroup, and a normal subgroup. Then:

  1. is a subgroup of , and ;
  2. ;
  3. , via .

Proof. (a) We have . For closure, , since by normality. For inverses, , since . Since is closed under conjugation by all of , it is in particular normal in .

(b) is a subgroup of (Proposition 2.4.4). If and , then because is a subgroup, and because ; so .

(c) Define by . This is a homomorphism, being the restriction to of the canonical projection . It is surjective: every element of has the form . Its kernel is . By the First Isomorphism Theorem, . ∎

Note. The name “Diamond Theorem” sometimes used for the Second Isomorphism Theorem comes from the picture of the four subgroups involved:

Diagram

The theorem identifies the quotient along the lower-left edge, , with the quotient along the opposite, upper-right edge, . (The other two edges are not paired in general: need not even be a group, since need not be normal in .) For finite groups, comparing orders gives .

Theorem 3.3.6 (Third Isomorphism Theorem). Let be a group and let be normal subgroups of . Then:

  1. is a normal subgroup of ;
  2. , via .

Proof. Define by . This is well defined by Theorem 3.3.2 applied to the projection , whose kernel contains ; and it is a surjective homomorphism, since is. Its kernel is . So is a kernel, hence normal in , and by the First Isomorphism Theorem . ∎

Note. The Third Isomorphism Theorem says “quotients of quotients are quotients”: , as if the ’s cancelled. This is exactly what one would hope for, and it is a sign that quotient groups are a natural and well-behaved construction.

3.3.3 The Correspondence Theorem

The last structural theorem describes the subgroups of a quotient in terms of the subgroups of the original group.

Theorem 3.3.7 (Correspondence Theorem). Let and let be the canonical projection. There is a bijection given by , with inverse . Moreover, for subgroups containing :

  1. if and only if , and in that case ;
  2. if and only if .

Proof. The image of a subgroup under a homomorphism is a subgroup, and so is the preimage (Proposition 2.5.2). So is a subgroup of , and is a subgroup of containing .

These operations are inverse to each other. Given , an element lies in if and only if for some , that is, for some ; since , this gives . Given , we have because is surjective.

(a) If , then ; conversely, if , then . For the index, consider the map from left cosets of in to left cosets of in , It is well defined and clearly surjective. It is injective: if , then , so and . Hence the two indices are equal.

(b) If , then for and we have , since . Conversely, if , then for and , , so . ∎

Question 3.3.8. Let and .

  1. List all subgroups of .
  2. For each, find the corresponding subgroup of containing .
  3. Which of these are normal in ? (Trick question!)
  4. Verify the Third Isomorphism Theorem by checking directly that .
Show solution

(a) is cyclic of order 12, so its subgroups are the for the divisors of 12 (Proposition 2.6.7): , of orders 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 12 respectively.

(b) For , an integer satisfies if and only if for some , which (since ) holds if and only if . So , and the correspondence is

(c) All of them: every subgroup of the abelian group is normal.

(d) We have , so the quotient has order . Explicitly, its elements are the cosets , , , . This group is cyclic of order 4, generated by the coset of , hence isomorphic to , as the Third Isomorphism Theorem predicts.

3.3.4 The Commutator Subgroup and Abelianization

Two constructions measure how far a group is from being abelian. The center (Definition 3.1.13) collects the elements that commute with everything; it is all of exactly when is abelian. The second construction goes the other way: it is the smallest normal subgroup whose quotient is abelian.

Definition 3.3.9 (Commutator subgroup and abelianization). The commutator of is ; it equals if and only if . The commutator subgroup is the subgroup generated by all commutators. Since , it consists of all finite products The quotient is the abelianization of .

Proposition 3.3.10 (Properties of the commutator subgroup). Let be a group.

  1. is a normal subgroup of .
  2. For , the quotient is abelian if and only if . In particular is abelian, and is abelian if and only if .
  3. Every homomorphism to an abelian group factors uniquely as , where is the canonical projection and is a homomorphism.

Proof. (a) For , as one sees by expanding the right side. Hence the conjugate of a product of commutators is again a product of commutators, so .

(b) In , . So is abelian if and only if for all , which holds if and only if contains the subgroup generated by the commutators.

(c) Since is abelian, , so every commutator lies in , and therefore . Now apply Theorem 3.3.2. ∎

So is the largest abelian quotient of : if is abelian, then , and by the Third Isomorphism Theorem is a quotient of . For an abelian group, . We compute the commutator subgroup of in Example 3.4.18, and the abelianization of a free group in Proposition 3.6.17.