From now on is a finite group. The basic tool is averaging over , which makes sense because is finite.
Lemma 13.2.1 (Invariant inner products). Let be a representation of . There is a positive-definite Hermitian inner product on (Definition 9.1.16) that is -invariant: for all and . In other words, every acts on by a unitary operator with respect to .
Proof. Let be any positive-definite Hermitian inner product on ; for instance, choose a basis and set . Average it over : Each term is conjugate-linear in , linear in , and satisfies , so is a Hermitian form. It is positive definite: for , every term is positive, since . It is -invariant: for , because runs over exactly once as does. ∎
Theorem 13.2.2 (Maschke’s Theorem). Let be a representation of a finite group , and let be a subrepresentation. Then there is a subrepresentation with .
Proof. Equip with a -invariant Hermitian inner product (Lemma 13.2.1), and let . By Theorem 9.1.31, . If , and , then , so Hence , and is a subrepresentation. ∎
There is a second proof, which uses no inner product. It works over any field in which , that is, with .
Proof (Second proof). Choose any complementary subspace , so that , and let be the projection onto along (so and ). Average it: Since takes values in and , so does . For , each lies in , so , and . The map is -equivariant: for , substituting , Let , a subrepresentation because is equivariant. Every is with and , because is the identity on . Also , again because is the identity on . So . ∎
Note. Both hypotheses matter. If acts on by , the line is invariant, but it is the only invariant line (it is the only line of eigenvectors of ), so it has no invariant complement; the same happens for acting by the same matrices. Here averaging is impossible because the group is infinite. Similarly, if has characteristic , the same matrices define a representation of on with no invariant complement to . This is one reason why modular representation theory, over fields whose characteristic divides , is harder. On the other hand, averaging still works for compact groups such as the circle or , with the sum over replaced by an integral, but we will not pursue this.
Corollary 13.2.3 (Complete reducibility). Every representation of a finite group is a direct sum of irreducible subrepresentations.
Proof. Induct on . If , it is the empty direct sum, and if is irreducible there is nothing to prove. Otherwise has a subrepresentation with , and by Maschke’s Theorem for a subrepresentation . Both and have smaller dimension than , so each is a direct sum of irreducible subrepresentations, and hence so is . ∎